Though each day may be dull or stormy, works of art are islands of joy. Nature and poetry evoke "Sehnsucht," that longing for Heaven C.S. Lewis described. Here we spend a few minutes enjoying those islands, those moments in the sun.
06 June 2013
Charles Williams blog is live!
My brand-new blog, "The Oddest Inkling," began its career yesterday! The first post is "An Introduction to Charles Williams". Please give it a read and leave your comments! Stay tuned in the next few weeks as more exciting announcements related to this project are unveiled.
01 June 2013
The Doctor Diaries III.1a
This
episode, one of my favorites, is the perfect opener for Series Three.
It is a far better first episode than those that opened the first two
seasons (in my opinion). I think it strikes just the right tone. It
is one of the more light-hearted episodes, and yet the Doctor faces
an enemy as dangerous as any other. The plasmavore is all the more
sinister because she takes the form of a little old lady—but more
on uncanny human resemblances in a later post. Putting the dear,
sweet blood-sucker aside for a moment, I love that the alien race
that dominates this story, the Judoon, are among the better species
we have encountered. I hate the idea that an entire species is
worthless by its very nature, fit only to destroy and be destroyed,
and this is often the concept given in Doctor Who.
The Cybermen and the Dalek are, simply because of what they are,
thoroughly evil. This, by the way, is one of the problems I have with
Tolkien's world: orcs are fit to be wiped from the face of the earth
like mosquitoes or flies, in spite of the fact that they are rational
beings who and think and talk. They are portrayed in Lord
of the Rings as beyond
redemption. And here again Doctor Who
rises to a new level: there are episodes in which the Doctor has to
acknowledge that even his worst enemies, the Dalek, are capable of
moral awareness and are fit to be saved rather than destroyed. All
that to say, I like the Judoon. They are disciplined, moral, and
just. Their justice is harsh, but they do nothing out of personal
malice. They are orderly, objective ministers of the law.
The
other reason I adore this episode is, of course, its christological
climax. The Doctor is called upon to sacrifice himself over and over
again throughout the course of the show, and he rushes to offer his
life as readily in exchange for that of one person as for the entire
planet earth. I'll blog more specifically about what I mean by
“christology” and all of its implications some other time. For
now, I just want to luxuriate in the beautiful sorrow of the crisis
in “Smith and Jones”: the Doctor gives his last drop of blood to
save half of humanity; Martha gives her last breath to save him. And
what makes this mutual sacrifice apart from real ones is that, by so
doing, they save each other. Neither ends up dying, but each is saved
in the other.
This
is very like an idea that is central to my academic work: the idea is
“co-inherence,” and it is the core teaching of the poet whose
works I study, Charles Williams. You might want to check out my other
blog, The
Oddest Inkling, which is dedicated to his work. He was a
peculiar fellow who mixed Christianity with the occult and who
gathered disciples around him to practice his particular version of
sanctity.
Co-inherence
is the idea that we are all members of one body, all part of one
another, and all able to live in and for each other. Co-inherence
teaches that Christ’s risen life is in each person who accepts Him;
therefore, we can share in the divine interrelationship of the
Trinity and live as members of one another.
In
1939, Charles Williams founded an “order” called the Companions
of the Co-inherence and laid down rules for them to follow as they
practiced co-inherence in action, also known as the Doctrine of
Substitution or the Way of Exchange. These exchanges are based on the
simple fact that everyone participates in physical exchange (I am
dependent on the farmers who produce my food; those who go to war die
in the place of those who stay home and for whom peace is purchased,
etc). We can choose to see these personal, social, and political
contacts as blessings and practice co-inherence in the strength of
Christ’s resurrections. We can make compacts to bear one another’s
burdens. We can voluntarily substitute ourselves for others and
“carry their burdens” quite literally, even though those burdens
may be spiritual, emotional, or medical. These principles can work
among the living in any space and time, and also with the dead and
the unborn.
The
clearest explication of “The Doctrine of Substituted Love” occurs
in Williams' novel Descent
into Hell.
One character is terrified of meeting her doppleganger.
Someone else offers to carry her fear for her. This happens, and she
is able to meet her double fearlessly.
The
ending of “Smith and Jones,” then, is an example of The Way of
Exchange in fiction. The Doctor chooses to die in exchange for the
lives of 3 billion people; Martha chooses to die in exchange for the
Doctor. His exchange works: no one on earth is killed by the
souped-up MRI. Her exchange works: the Doctor is revived by her last
breath. And the blessing that results from Martha's sacrifice is that
his resuscitation results in hers, so the circle is closed: the
Doctor saves the people, Martha saves the Doctor, so then the Doctor
saves Martha without sacrificing himself again.
And
they all live happily ever after.....?
30 May 2013
index to CW book summaries
I had begun summarizing CW's works in chronological order and posting the summaries on this blog. However, since I am launching my brand-new CW blog, THE ODDEST INKLING, next week, I will post these summaries there from now one. Enjoy!
Index to summaries of books by Charles Williams:
1912 -- The Silver Stair -- poetry (sonnet sequence)
1912 -- The Chapel of the Thorn -- unpublished play ("dramatic poem")
1917 -- Poems of Conformity -- poetry on love and war
1920 -- Divorce -- poems
Index to summaries of books about Charles Williams:
1983 -- Hadfield, Alice Mary. Charles Williams: An Exploration of His Life and Work
Index to summaries of books by Charles Williams:
1912 -- The Silver Stair -- poetry (sonnet sequence)
1912 -- The Chapel of the Thorn -- unpublished play ("dramatic poem")
1917 -- Poems of Conformity -- poetry on love and war
1920 -- Divorce -- poems
Index to summaries of books about Charles Williams:
1983 -- Hadfield, Alice Mary. Charles Williams: An Exploration of His Life and Work
28 May 2013
The Doctor Diaries III: Xmas special
“The
Runaway Bride” and The Ultimate Things
What
makes a work of fiction terribly powerful? What makes it memorable?
What makes it emotionally wrenching? One factor is often how it deals
with The Ultimate Things: birth, death, and the end of the world.
I've written a bit about The
End of the World in fiction previously.
According
to Christian theology, there are either Four Last Things: Death,
Judgment, Heaven, and Hell, or Seven Last Things: the second coming
of Christ, the defeat of antichrist, the binding of Satan, the
millennial kingdom, the release of Satan, the last judgment (a.k.a.
the end of the world), and the revelation of the new heaven and the
new earth. These are often presented archetypally in fiction,
especially the defeat of antichrist: the protagonist and antagonist
are often presented as being equal-but-opposite to each other,
necessary to one another's continued purpose and/or existence. This
is presented most clearly in fiction of the comic book, superhero,
and epic kinds. See, for instance, the (SPOILERS!) ending of
Unbreakable
or Sherlock
and Moriarty's last conversation. Since the “good guy”
and the “bad guy” are presented as complimentary opposites, or
foils for one another, this is typologically resonant with the
theological concept of Christ defeating Antichrist.
Another
factor in making a work of fiction terrifically powerful is how it
pushes its characters to the extremes of human action and emotion,
which might be considered another set of Ultimate Things: murder,
suicide, star-crossed love affairs, betrayal, loss of a child, loss
of the beloved, salvation, and damnation.
The
characters in Doctor Who
encounter one of the
Ultimate Things in nearly every episode. That's as much part of the
genre as the fights with silly aliens or the Doctor's obsession with
picking up pretty young companions.
In “The
Runaway Bride,” the Doctor takes Donna to witness the beginning of
the Earth. It turns out that the particularly overdone villain in
this episode (a giant red spider who apparently can't walk and just
stands in place listening to all her children being murdered) was
there at the creation of earth—in fact, she caused earth's
beginnings by using her spaceship as the first rock in the center of
a cluster, thus creating a gravity field that began drawing in all
the other rocks and space debris around it. All this rubble
eventually coalesced into the planet we know and love.
Anyway,
the point is that Donna gets to witness the birth of the Planet
Earth. This is obviously quite a ultimate Ultimate Thing. And it has
on her exactly the effect the Doctor planned; Donna is singularly
gifted at missing the Big Picture. She missed the invasion of the
Sycorax because she had a hangover. She was unaware of World War
Three because she was scuba diving off the coast of Spain. So the
Doctor decides she needs a little perspective in her life. And what
better way to infuse a bit of Big-Picture Perspective than to shove a
little human right into the middle of one of the Ultimate Things? And
which Ultimate Thing could be better than one that no human has ever
seen before, which is beyond human ability to observe? It's like
watching one's own birth—only it's more like watching everyone's
birth,
at once.
And
it works. Donna says, “That puts the wedding into perspective.”
Indeed it does. It puts most everything into perspective. That what
The Ultimate Things does, and I believe that is one reason that
fiction of the epic, fantasy, and comic book types are so popular,
and always will be—at least until we experience the Ultimate Things
themselves directly, without fictional mediation. /
25 May 2013
The Doctor Diaries: Interim
As a
late-blooming Whovian, I made an awkward entry into the series by
watching Seasons Five, Two, and One—in that order. I had actually
tried Season One, but was so turned off by Christopher Eccleston's
big ears and funny face, Billie Piper's unclassy accent, and the
absurdity of the plots in the first three episodes that I quit
watching. It was such awful B-movie scifi. But then, on the advice of
several very savvy friends, I randomly jumped into Season Five. I
don't know whatever possessed me to skip The One and Only Doctor,
David Tennant. But even sweet, silly Matt Smith got me over the goofy
stories and into the profound depths of the Steven Moffat stories.
So, I rather hope that's part of their grand scheme. We'll see.
All that
to say: I haven't been blogging the Doctor for a while because I went
back and watched Season One. And of course, I fell in love and got my
heart broken with the rest of you. Yet not journalling about those
episodes is no great loss, I think, because of the cyclical nature of
the series. Each deep theme gets revisited at some point in the
“future” (funny how the very nature of the Doctor messes with the
meanings of words like “future”).
This
also gives me a chance to blog about another Big Idea the Doctor has
given me. I'm calling it Retrospective Linearity.
That's
a big name for a fairly basic idea. The idea is that at the end of
the whole Doctor Who
experience, you could go back and reconstruct human history, in
order, from beginning to end, to show how the Doctor created that
history. He does not visit historical events in order—that is, in
order from his perspective, according to when he encounters them
relative to his personal chronology—but the chains of
cause-and-effect he puts into motion end up spanning human history.
Here are
the historical events and people he has visited, in his order, since
the reboot:
1. Charles Dickens
2. World War II, the London Blitz
3. Queen Victoria
4. Madame de Pompadour
5. the coronation of Elizabeth I
6. the 2012 London Olympics (although this was in the future when the Doctor visited)
7. Shakespeare
8. the construction of the Empire State Building
9. 1913, right before the start of World War I
10. HMS Titanic
11. Pompeii, A.D. 79
12. Agatha Christie
13. Winston Churchill
14. 16th century Venice
15. Vincent van Gogh
16. 17th century pirate ship
17. Christmas Eve, 1938
18. Queen Nefertiti
19. American Wild West in the 19th century
20. London, 1892
21. the Cold War
1. Charles Dickens
2. World War II, the London Blitz
3. Queen Victoria
4. Madame de Pompadour
5. the coronation of Elizabeth I
6. the 2012 London Olympics (although this was in the future when the Doctor visited)
7. Shakespeare
8. the construction of the Empire State Building
9. 1913, right before the start of World War I
10. HMS Titanic
11. Pompeii, A.D. 79
12. Agatha Christie
13. Winston Churchill
14. 16th century Venice
15. Vincent van Gogh
16. 17th century pirate ship
17. Christmas Eve, 1938
18. Queen Nefertiti
19. American Wild West in the 19th century
20. London, 1892
21. the Cold War
Now let
me re-order those to match earth's history:
1. Queen Nefertiti
2. Pompeii, A.D. 79
3, 16th century Venice
4. Shakespeare
5. 17th century pirate ship
6. Madame de Pompadour
7. Charles Dickens
8. Queen Victoria
9. American Wild West in the 19th century
10. Vincent van Gogh
11. London, 1892
12. HMS Titanic
13. 1913, right before the start of World War I
14. Agatha Christie
15. the construction of the Empire State Building
16. Christmas Eve, 1938
17. World War II, the London Blitz
18. Winston Churchill
19. the coronation of Elizabeth I
20. the Cold War
21.the 2012 London Olympics
1. Queen Nefertiti
2. Pompeii, A.D. 79
3, 16th century Venice
4. Shakespeare
5. 17th century pirate ship
6. Madame de Pompadour
7. Charles Dickens
8. Queen Victoria
9. American Wild West in the 19th century
10. Vincent van Gogh
11. London, 1892
12. HMS Titanic
13. 1913, right before the start of World War I
14. Agatha Christie
15. the construction of the Empire State Building
16. Christmas Eve, 1938
17. World War II, the London Blitz
18. Winston Churchill
19. the coronation of Elizabeth I
20. the Cold War
21.the 2012 London Olympics
This, of
course, doesn't include any time the Doctor visited in his first
eight regenerations. Here is my point: The show gradually,
non-chronologically reveals that the entirety of human history was
written by the Doctor. At every moment, he stepped in to save earth,
to save the human race.
At
least, that's what I think the show could do, or should do, over
time, as it layers more and more historical visits on top of one
another. You'll notice that in 7 seasons, well over 70 episodes, he
has only visited 21 times in the past—all the rest have been in the
future. If they play it right, they could reveal how history was, at
every moment, about to be different—disastrous—ending! —but the
Doctor stepped in and made it what it now has been. And Steven Moffat
& Co. are perfectly capable of constructing this elaborate
historical revisionism.
So, I rather hope that's part of their grand scheme. We'll see.
10 May 2013
Announcing the Charles Williams blog
Hear ye, hear ye!
On Wednesday June 5th, 2013,
a new venue for Inklings information, discussion, and interaction
will appear.
will appear.
It is my new blog, entitled:
THE ODDEST INKLING
An Exploration of the Works of Charles Williams (1886-1945)
This new blog is hosted by WordPress, and you can see the dummy site here.
I will begin by offering weekly posts
-- "Charles Williams Wednesdays" ! --
covering the following topics:
I will begin by offering weekly posts
-- "Charles Williams Wednesdays" ! --
covering the following topics:
1. The Life
2. His Themes
3. The Works (summaries of CW's books, in chronological order)
3. The Works (summaries of CW's books, in chronological order)
4. Bibliography (Secondary Sources)
5. Influencers and Influenced
6. Arthuriana
7. Rosicruciana
8. Academic Articles (Paper Abstracts, Selections, and Links)
9. News (Calls for Papers, new links, media, etc.)
I will begin by collecting, revising, and tidying the Charles Williams-related material on this blog and moving it over to that one in a neat and organized fashion. Then I will start generating new content, especially book summaries, with the goal of one post a week
-- "Charles Williams Wednesdays"--
Meanwhile . . .
please contact me
(iambic[dot]admonit[at]gmail[dot]com)
if you have ideas for posts, themes, discussions, books to summarize, books to review, guest bloggers, material you would like to post, etc.
Thank you, and I hope you join me in exploring
THE ODDEST INKLING,
Charles Walter Stansby Williams.
-- "Charles Williams Wednesdays"--
Meanwhile . . .
please contact me
(iambic[dot]admonit[at]gmail[dot]com)
if you have ideas for posts, themes, discussions, books to summarize, books to review, guest bloggers, material you would like to post, etc.
Thank you, and I hope you join me in exploring
THE ODDEST INKLING,
Charles Walter Stansby Williams.
26 April 2013
This article should be illegal.
I have just had a piece entitled "Arthur, Adapted" published in Curator.
It should be illegal because it is a "review" of a book that has not yet been released and which I have
not yet read.
The book is The Fall of Arthur by J.R.R. Tolkien, scheduled for release from Houghton Mifflin Harcourt on May 23rd, 2013. You can pre-order it on Amazon.
So in my little Curator piece, I go through a little
bit of literary history and a little bit of literary analysis about the story of King Arthur, about adaptation, and about urtexts.
I talk about why the King Arthur story is perennially popular.
Then I provide some "semi-oracular statements" about what I think Tolkien’s work will contain and what it will be like. Please read the whole article and give me your thoughts! Thank you.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

