The Power of Music
In my post about “The Shakespeare Code,” I wrote about the saving, magical power of words. Now this episode concludes with a victory based on the power of music.
This is a gorgeous concept: I hope that every one of you readers has had your heart wrenched, your soul uplifted, and your life changed by listening to live music, especially orchestral, operatic, chamber ensemble, piano, or organ music (I find those to be the most powerful). And if you have, perhaps you wondered what exactly was going on. Why should a particular combination of mechanical waves, setting up patterns of oscillating pressure in air (thanks, wikipedia), make me cry or make me feel like I am in heaven?
Well, words do the same thing, and words are also sounds; i.e., mechanical waves setting up patterns of oscillating pressure in air. And any particular set of those mechanical waves, originating at someone else's mouth and ending at my ear, to be processed by my brain, can cause me to cry or laugh or want to die or think I'm in heaven.
But words are different. Words carry meaning. We could have a delightful conversation about whether the meanings words convey are simply arbitrary social conventions, or whether they have an essential relationship with the sounds of the words themselves. But either way, there is something astonishing about how sound waves cause emotional reactions, even when they have no textual meaning.
Why should a Chopin prelude sound sad? It's not that the series of notes sound like certain sad words (in English, or Polish, or any language). Why should Beethoven's Third Symphony sound victorious? It is only because the rhythms and the instrumentation resemble traditional military music? Or is it more than that? Is all of this also only culturally constructed? A minor scale doesn't necessarily sound sad to someone who grew up listening to scales involving microtones.
I don't know the answers to those questions. But the point is, however music has its effect, and whatever kinds of music have particular effects in certain cultures: music is very powerful.
And in “The Lazarus Experiment,” it is powerful enough to kill.
This is not an original idea, although used to great effect in this episode. I encountered deadly music previously in The Nine Tailors by Dorothy L. Sayers: it's my favorite of all her books (so far; Gaudy Night and Busman's Honeymoon are waiting for me at the library right now). But I can't say any more. Even that much is a bit of a spoiler. After you read The Nine Tailors, check out this amazing sock knitted in its honor.
Yet the music in “The Lazarus Experiment” doesn't only kill; it also saves.
By killing the monster (to whom he had already given chance after chance), the Doctor saves Martha, Letitia, and possibly the whole human race.
Before I go, I do have one more point to make. When the Doctor plays the organ (so much fun!), he doesn't play a piece of music. He just plays random chords as he tries to find just the right combination of pitches that will destroy the monster. Later, though, Martha says that she didn't know he plays the organ. He says, “Well, you know, you hang around with Beethoven, you're bound to pick a few things up.” That's cute.
But Beethoven isn't really known for organ music. Here is the rather short list of Beethoven's works for organ. Didn't the Doctor mean Bach?
Though each day may be dull or stormy, works of art are islands of joy. Nature and poetry evoke "Sehnsucht," that longing for Heaven C.S. Lewis described. Here we spend a few minutes enjoying those islands, those moments in the sun.
22 June 2013
20 June 2013
The Doctor Diaries III.4 & 5b: “Daleks in Manhattan” and “Evolution of the Daleks”
Professor
Diggins' Dragons
I
wrote yesterday that I used to get really annoyed every time the
Daleks appeared again, until I realize that each
time they are threatening different humans, so the Doctor has to
intervene over and over again, to save different people.
This
has, I believe, a metaphorical application:
The
sci-fi enemies represent the recurring problems that humans face over
and over and over again. Every human faces the same temptations, the
same tragedies, the same weaknesses, the same challenges. We don't
really learn by example. We make the same mistakes our parents and
grandparents and ancient ancestors made. We suffer the same diseases.
So
the Daleks, Cybermen, Carrionites, Sycorax, Weeping Angels, Family of
Blood, and all the other enemies recur, season after season, just as
we suffer in the same ways, generation after generation, day after
day.
This
is one way that someone who is not usually a sci-fi fan could perhaps
come to enjoy Doctor
Who.
I mean, even I hate these stupid aliens and overdone monsters.
But
they're metaphors. None of us will ever face a Dalek (well, we might
dredge
one up in a pond somewhere), but each enemy represents
something awful that we actually do fight every day.
The
Cybermen could represent our addictions to technology and our
increasing willingness to allow the virtual world to take over our
identities.
(I type this as I'm following the #BenedictCumberbatch hashtag on twitter and clicking on all the pictures).
The
Daleks could represent our proclivity towards racism and genocide.
The
Family of Blood could be an embodiment of ways in which we prioritize
our own tribe, culture, and other in-group over other people's needs.
The
Weeping Angels will get a post of their own!
Oh,
and by the way, what's with the title of this post? Professor
Diggins' Dragons19 June 2013
The Doctor Diaries III.4 & 5a: “Daleks in Manhattan” and “Evolution of the Daleks”
The Doctor Is Not Jesus!
I
used to get really annoyed every time the Daleks appeared again.
First of all, they're very silly. Their ridiculous computer-generated
voices grate on my ears. Their pepper-pot shape drives me crazy. Their arbitrary decisions about when to exterminate and when to stand
there like idiots for the convenience of the plot pushed me beyond
endurance.
But
then I realized why it is important that the same enemies come back
over and over again and why the Doctor has to defeat them time and
time again. After each encounter, he believes he has eradicated them
for good. Each time, they come back and threaten humanity again.
The
reason this matters is that each
time they are threatening different
humans.
Each
human needs to be saved, each time. So he saved the earth from Daleks
in 2005; well, he needs to save the world from them again in 2007, or
in 5100, or in 300 B.C., because the earth contains different people
every time. Some have been born and others have died in the
intervening time, and he has to save them all, over and over and
over.
I
see two matters of thematic importance as a result. I'll post this
theme today and another one tomorrow.
First,
this is a major difference between the Doctor and Jesus. I blogged
last time about how the Doctor is a “Christ-figure” in the
literary sense. But Jesus only gave Himself once. The Doctor has to
give himself over and over and over.
Now,
there are a lot of things I could say about that.
I
could talk about how the Doctor doesn't really die; he's always saved
at the last minute. There are a few times that he does die, though,
and then something wibbly-wobbly has to happen to reset time the way
it was supposed to be.
That
could lead me to talk about Predestination: the Way Things Were Meant
To Be. Think back to Series One, the episode “Father's Day.” Pete
Tyler was “supposed” to die that day, and when he didn't, the
entire universe began to fall apart and everyone else was destroyed.
But who said he was supposed to die that day? Did God ordain it? Did
it have something to do with linear time, like a story—since he
died the “first time” through that time, he had to the “second
time” through that time? (we'll come back to that later).
Or
I could talk about resurrection and regeneration; is every kind of
regeneration/rebirth/return in literature always a symbol of
resurrection? Or is resurrection just our longing for regeneration
turned into a wish-fulfillment doctrine?
Or
I could get into the symbolic ways in which Jesus' sacrifice is
remembered over and over again, such as in baptism and the Lord's
Supper. In Roman Catholic Christianity, of course, the sacrifice is
literal in each celebration of the Mass: the elements become Christ's
body and blood, thus enacting His death and resurrection over again
for each believer. So maybe in that sense the Doctor's repetitive
sacrifice is still a very accurate spiritual symbol.
Or
I could talk about another important part of the Dying-and-rising-god
conversation. In most other religions that have a
Dying-and-rising-god (besides Christianity, I mean), the god's life
cycle is tied to the cycle of the seasons: he or she dies and rises
every year, and the resurrection is connected to the regeneration of
plants in the springtime. So another argument against Christianity is
that it is just another permutation of these seasonal cycle myths:
after all, Easter is celebrated in the springtime. The opposite
argument is possible, too: that all the other seasonal cycle myths
are wish-fulfillment and Christianity is the real thing that happened
just once, historically.
Which
brings me back around to where I started. Jesus died just once, in an
efficacious, substitutionary atonement with eternal consequences. In
this piece of fiction, even within the fictional world (unlike, say,
Aslan, whose sacrifice occurred only once), the Doctor's sacrifices
do not stick. He has to do it over and over and over again.
Of
course, that's also just necessary to keep the show going. If he went
back to the beginning of time and did something so huge that it
destroyed the Daleks, Cybermen, Carrionites, Sycorax, and Weeping
Angels all in one go, there wouldn't be any story.
Come
back tomorrow to read about the other theme this brings to mind!
18 June 2013
The Doctor Diaries III.3 “Gridlock”
New-new-new-new-new-new-new-new-new-new-new-new-new-new-new
Old Story
As
you know by now, I am “reading” Doctor Who through
two sets of lenses: English-teacher glasses, and Christian glasses.
I'm looking at them as I look at carefully-crafted works of
literature, searching for literature devices, structure, cultural
significance, mythical resonance, and theological implications.
That's how my mind works. Sci-fi is a perfect venue for communicating
the deeper truths about humanity, because it can use the wildest
physical metaphors imaginable, not being restricted by a particular
set of historical events or a narrow segment of current science.
Sci-fi also taps into the most profound traditions of fantasy and
mythology, which means it uses the collective human imagination's
most enduring archetypes to communicate emotionally and spiritually.
And
“Gridlock” employs what I believe is the most profound archetype
of all: the Christ-figure. The entirety of Doctor Who is
arguably “about” how the Doctor is a symbol of Christ, so I know
I will come back to this idea again and again. I would like to
deepen, clarify, and enrich my thoughts on this point, so I would
love it if somebody wanted to debate with me about this. In the
meanwhile, “Gridlock” makes its christological references
very obvious, so it's a good place to begin delving into this idea
more deeply.
Let's
go through a few of the background ideas first.
There
are only a few plots in the world—only a handful of narrative
shapes that stories can take.
Here
is a
list of “Master Plots,” and here are the
Seven Basic Plots. I'll talk about a few that came into my mind
before reading those lists.
There's
the Cinderella plot, in which someone goes from rags-to-riches either
literally or figuratively. I think that Hobbit-like
plots, in which a small person achieves great things, is a variation
on this theme. I think that the making-of-a-hero story (Batman
Begins, Man of Steel, etc.) is
another such variation.
There's
the Rake's progress story, the slow downward trajectory of a bad
person—or even an ordinary person—getting gradually worse.
There's
the Tragic Hero's demise, usually in a kind of
recognition-and-reversal arrangement, on the classical model of
Oedipus.
There's
the basic Marriage Plot, moving characters towards pairing off, often
involving mistaken identity, miscommunication, and disguises before
the resolution.
They
can be combined, such as the common union of the Cinderella plot with
the Marriage Plot.
There
are a few other patterns. Can you name some?
And
there is the ubiquitous Creation→
Fall→ Redemption story, which is also the Birth→
Death→Resurrection story.
It could be argued that this is the oldest, most wide-spread, and
most powerful plot arc. It might be the most common. I don't know
whether it occurs more frequently than the others, or in more
permutations. But I do know that when combined with a strong,
admirable main character, especially when that main character chooses
sacrifice, it is one of the most moving.
Now,
I'm a Christian. And Christianity is a narrative religion. We base
our faith on a Story. On a double-layered story, actually: it's
Creation → Fall → Redemption and Birth → Death →
Resurrection. It's historical, divine, and personal. It's linear and
cyclical, universal and individual.
The
ubiquity of the Creation→Fall→Redemption/
Birth→Death→Resurrection narrative could present a problem to
Christian belief, especially because it occurs in so very many other
religions, including ones that appear to have developed before or
independently of Christianity. In other words, if this is such a
common human story, what makes the Christian one any more likely to
be true?
Or
let me approach that question another way. How can the Christian
story and all these other stories be so similar, if there were no
obvious cultural or literary imitations from one to another?
There
are lots of possible answers.
1.
Somebody came up with a Birth→Death→Resurrection story way back
in the beginning of human history, and it got passed around by
word-of-mouth from culture to culture, so all the others are just
copying that one.
2.
There is something in the human imagination, perhaps something like
Jung's
“collective
unconscious,”
that makes us all love the same stories, regardless of our culture,
education, reading, or anything—so we all come up with the
Birth→Death→Resurrection story, independently.
3.
The early Christians and the writers of the Gospels were copying one
or more of the older stories.
4.
Jesus' Birth→Death→Resurrection really happened, and it's just a
coincidence that this pattern resembles so many earlier stories and
stories from other cultures.
5.
God planned all along that Jesus' life would follow that pattern, so
He planted the Birth→Death→Resurrection story into the human
imagination, intending for lots and lots of poets to tell the story
all over the world before Jesus came and acted it out for real, so
that then people would be primed and ready to accept it.
6.
There is something so inevitable about the Birth→Death→Resurrection
pattern that the universe just has to follow it. That is the way
things are, on the personal level, in history, and on the divine
scale. Even if Jesus' life had not happened yet, it would eventually
have to happen just that way, because Birth→Death→Resurrection is
the only way things can possibly unfold.
So
there are some possible answers. Can you suggest some others?
Numbers
1, 2, and 3 are the most commonly believed in American culture just
now, I would say.
#5
is C.S. Lewis'.
#6
is Charles Williams'.
I
suggest that #2 is Doctor Who's.
Now,
let's finally talk about “Gridlock.” In every episode, the Doctor
does something self-sacrificial to save someone else, frequently to
save everyone else. He is willing to die, over and over and over,
that others may live. Obviously that's based on the Christ-pattern,
whichever of those interpretations you accept. Usually the Doctor's
selfless love goes un-interpreted. But in “Gridlock,” the
association becomes as clear as it can be without a character yelling
out, “He's like Jesus!”
It's
made clear by the music. As everyone's driving along, year after
year, stuck on the motorway, they get a musical interlude on the
radio, and they all stop to listen to hymns. Specifically, they
listen to “The Old Rugged Cross,” whose lyrics are just about a
clear a statement of the Gospel as you will find. When the song first
started playing, I cringed, thinking that of course this was going to
be parody, mockery. I was certain the screenwriters would be making
fun of the characters for their archaic, meaningless faith. While
that potential was there, however, Martha's and the Doctor's
reactions led to a much different reading.
They
take the hymn seriously. Martha starts to cry. She even sings along.
And
then later, Martha made the statement that created an explicit
analogy between Jesus and the Doctor. She shouted to the residents of
New New York: “You have your hymns and your fiath. I have the
Doctor!” In other words, they have the same thing (literarily
speaking).
I
hope to continue digging into this idea as we proceed, and to point
out some of the important differences between the Doctor and
Jesus in my next post. Please stay tuned.
17 June 2013
King Arthur was an Elf
The Fall of Arthur is AMAZING! It has rocked my world. I hope it rocks your world. It contains information that should make us re-evaluate all of Tolkien's works, plus some of Lewis' and Williams', as well.
But I won't give away the secret here. You have to read it. And then you have to read my review on Curator in a few weeks.
Meanwhile... Did you get to read my "illegal" article on Curator a few weeks ago? Well, here it is, a pre-review of The Fall of Arthur by J.R.R. Tolkien. In it, I made a bunch of predictions about the poem before reading it.
Now I get to rate myself as a prophet.
I'm writing a proper review for Curator, which will appear in due course. Meanwhile, how did I do? Am I oracular? Here are the predictions I made, and my evaluation of them now that I've read the book.
7. I talked about his concept of absolutism in language. Well, this one is hard to judge. I can't point to any specific moments that go either way.
8. I predicted that it would be a good poem, with a lively meter, vivid imagery and beautiful sounds, but not a great poem. Right. Excellent, masterful meter, but awkward inverted syntax, some amazing descriptions, and a surprisingly lively plot.
But I won't give away the secret here. You have to read it. And then you have to read my review on Curator in a few weeks.
Meanwhile... Did you get to read my "illegal" article on Curator a few weeks ago? Well, here it is, a pre-review of The Fall of Arthur by J.R.R. Tolkien. In it, I made a bunch of predictions about the poem before reading it.
Now I get to rate myself as a prophet.
I'm writing a proper review for Curator, which will appear in due course. Meanwhile, how did I do? Am I oracular? Here are the predictions I made, and my evaluation of them now that I've read the book.
1. I said that The Fall of Arthur will be a thoroughly
twentieth-century work. I got this one wrong. It is thoroughly imitative of two sources: the Norse/Old English poetry from which it takes its form, and the later Frenchified romances on King Arthur.
2. I predicted that there would be
echoes of the First World War in the battle scenes. I got this one wrong. There was only a sea battle, and it was quite Viking in its atmosphere.
3. I said there would be a feeling of
hopelessness in the Battle of Camlann,
counteracted by the individual heroism of ordinary people. Wrong on both counts; the fragment doesn't get as far as that battle, and there are no ordinary people; only big characters. There is a Frisian sea captain who does something heroic, but it's for the wrong reasons, and he goes to hell for it (!).
4. I said that the little
knight whose name has been forgotten will do deeds to rival those of
Gawain, Lancelot and Arthur himself. Wrong. See #3 above.
5. I thought that if The Fall of Arthur contains a description of what T.S. Eliot called “The Wasteland,” it would be seen through Tolkien’s radical environmental vision. Well, there is no such description. So, wrong.
6. I said that there
would be “Victorian” depictions of stylized women. Right, but Guinevere is a very strong, powerful, active, complex character, even though she has an elvish beauty.
8. I predicted that it would be a good poem, with a lively meter, vivid imagery and beautiful sounds, but not a great poem. Right. Excellent, masterful meter, but awkward inverted syntax, some amazing descriptions, and a surprisingly lively plot.
9. I said that this poem would show off Tolkien's mythopoeic genius. Right, right, right again. Just wait until you see how right! Whew.
10. And finally, I said that Tolkien gave up this poem because wanted to refigure the mythic power of the
Christian religion, to
rewrite it in an entirely new universe of his own creation. Well, perhaps, but I think I have to count this one wrong -- because he found a way to do both! Or perhaps, although he found the way, it was not satisfactory in the end, since he didn't end up using this method in the poem itself, only in his notes. So I'm going to say I'm right on this one.
That's still not a very good score: 4 out of 10?
I fail as a prophet.
I guess I'll stick to literary analysis.
BUT YOU: GO READ THE BOOK !
The Doctor Diaries III.2 “The Shakespeare Code"
Secret, Magical Words
There
are many aspects of this episode I could talk about, since it is
packed with literary treats. I'm going to pick out just one: the idea
of magical words.
Of
course, this has to be my favorite episode. Even if there are others
that tug my heartstrings more, stories that go deeper and further,
events that lift me higher, I have to pick this episode as my
personal favorite, since it was obviously written for English majors
and English teachers. Oh, it is delightful.
There
are many aspects of this episode I could talk about, since it is
packed with literary treats. I'm going to pick out just one: the idea
of magical words.
It
is the magic of words that saves the world. Of course, though, the
words are not magical. There is a quasi-scientific explanation for
everything in Doctor
Who, no
matter how far-fetched. You know that sounds can actually do things
here, in the real world. The right pitch can break glass. I heard a
radio program once about scientists trying to develop a way of
targeting cancer cells with the right musical pitch. So in “The
Shakespeare Code,” the Carrionites use words “to channel energy.”
The Doctor compares it to quantum physics: “Given
the right string numbers, the right equation, you can split the atom.
Carrionites use words instead.” So the words are not magical: they
are merely the exact sequence of musical pitches and rhythmical beats
to set up the proper energy patterns and cause things to happen in
the universe: a rift to open for the Carrionites to come through,
then the rift to suck all the Carrionites back through and close for
good.
Now,
the idea of using the power of well-ordered words to channel energy
is ancient, in both magic and mysticism. Much magic relies on
incantations: particular words chanted in a particular order to yield
particular results. But there is another side to the concept of
magical words that is practiced in mysticism and even survives in a
diluted form in the most respectable churches. Many churches have a
liturgy that they follow. What is a liturgy but a series of organized
words? These words are said week after week, year after year,
millennium after millennium. They are intend to have actual spiritual
effects: to prompt the practitioner into repentance, humility,
exaltation, and a sense of union with God.
In
Mysticism, the practice is even more literal. I want to talk
particularly about one mystical tradition: the Qabalah.
You
will see this name spelled many different ways: Cabbalah, Kabalah,
etc. Some scholars auger that the spelling indicates a specific
meaning. I haven't gotten that far yet. But the Qabalah is a system
of Jewish mysticism that (among other things) teaches meditation on
the Name of God: on the letters
of
the name of God. The enlightened Qabalistic mystic is supposed to be
able to achieve a higher state of consciousness by writing these
letters over and over, reciting them, visualizing them, and so forth.
What
is this but another form of the magic of words?
The
idea of powerful, secret words runs through some of the deep-rooted
traditions of English literature. It is important in the legends
about King Arthur, which have had a profound influence on the English
consciousness.
One
early important
Arthurian poet was named Robert de Boron. He wrote in French in the
late twelfth and early thirteenth centuries. He writes about the Holy
Grail. In his version, Sir
Perceval becomes the Keeper of the Grail, and Perceval is also given
charge of secret
words
that are powerful and operative. This idea was passed down in many
versions of the legends.
These
ideas suddenly became really important again in England in the early
20th
century, when various scientific, political, and religious factors
led to an “occult revival” in which many people joined secret
societies. So the idea of magical, mystical, powerful words
influenced several writers who were in these groups: A.E.
Waite, W.B.
Yeats, Aleister Crowley, Algernon Blackwood, Arthur Machen, Evelyn
Underhill, and Charles
Williams.
They all practiced various kinds of incantations and meditations with
or on words that they believed were spiritually powerful.
And
then more recently and more popularly, this idea of magical, secret
words appared in the Harry Potter series. The children are taught
particular words to say for each spell. While Rowling never meditates
on the metaphysics of this magic, words are obviously essential to
the working of magic.
Then
in
Harry
Potter and the Deathly Hallows,
there is a secret, esoteric teaching handed down by word-of-mouth.
This occult message promises that when the Elder Wand, Resurrection
Stone, and Invisibility Cloak are “united,”
they will “make the possessor master of Death” (Rowling Deathly
Hallows 410),
“which has usually been understood to mean that they will be
invulnerable, even immortal” (Rowling, Tales
of Beedle the Bard 96).
The Deathly Hallows are very like the Grail Hallows of Arthurian
legend, as Denise Roper explains in her fun book The Lord of the Hallows.
But
Harry
eventually rejects this secret teaching, choosing to ignore it in his
determination to act out ultimate love via self-sacrifice.
Isn't
that just like the Doctor? While he uses the magical words—or
persuades Shakespeare to use them—he always choose plain
old-fashioned self-sacrifice over some kind of magical pyrotechnics.
And even here, when magical words are used, they
are from Harry
Potter!
So
magical words traveled through King Arthur stories through occult
poets into Harry Potter and then into Doctor
Who
(whether by direct descent or sub-conscious imagination doesn't
matter here), but the final messages about love and sacrifice are the
same.
14 June 2013
The Doctor Diaries III.1b: Smith and Jones
Some Notes on Names and Narrators
Have you noticed that all of the Doctor's companions and hangers-on are very ordinary people with common names? Rose Tyler, Mickey Smith, Martha Jones, Sarah Jane Smith, Donna Noble.... I think there are a couple of reasons for this.
[Yes, Amelia Pond has a fairy-tale name, and she turns out to be pretty important—but that doesn't invalidate my main ideas here. Hold on.]
First, the point is that he is not picking out someone who is “special” in the world's eyes: not someone famous, or extra-talented, or noteworthy. He's not even really picking people out; he stumbles across someone's path, or she stumbles across his, and they have a connection, and so he invites her along.
The point with that scenario is that any ordinary person has the potential to do really amazing things. An uneducated, lower-class shop girl can save the world, over and over and over, or become a conduit for the Time Vortex, gaining power over life and death, out of the depths of her love and self-sacrifice. A hard-working, intelligent, but otherwise unremarkable medical student can reveal all the truly remarkable depths and complexities of her nature when paired with the Doctor and faced with peril and adventure.
So that's the first point: There are no ordinary humans. Every one can be amazing if given the chance. But that's the point within the narrative, taking the characters as people, inhabiting the world of the fiction.
There is another purpose for the ordinary names altogether when we look at Doctor Who from a literary point of view. This has to do with the narrator. Wait, you say, there is no narrator. There is (thankfully) no voiceover—except in a few odd episodes like “Love and Monsters”, but that's an exception with its own particular purpose. Television is not like written fiction.
When a story is written down, there has to be somebody telling the story. You remember those lessons in high school English class about the narrator: first or third person, limited or omniscient? A movie takes a totally different approach, by filming perspective. It could be filmed from just one character's perspective, but that is rare. I have written a bit about perspective here, in this post about The Hunger Games.
But there is another narrative matter I want to discuss now. I believe that the Doctor Who team used companions with ordinary names because they represent us. Each one is an EveryHuman. She stands in for us, observing the Doctor as we would observe him. This is very important. It is very important to have an outside, ordinary perspective on a Genius or otherwise extraordinary character, so that the reader/viewer will have a way in, a way of understanding the Genius and his relationship to “normal” people. In written fiction, this person often tells the story, so that the reader can identify with the narrator's responses to the Genius. It would be more difficult to identify with the Genius directly, so the writer often puts in an ordinary guy or girl so that we have a way in. Even when the main character is not a genius, but merely someone out of the ordinary in one way or another, we often need a mundane character to bring us in. Even when the narrator does not speak in first person, there is often an ordinary person at the heart of the action.
- We read Sherlock Holmes through the eyes and words of John Watson. (watch this)
- Lord of the Rings is told mostly from a hobbit's perspective, not from a king's or a wizard's.
- The Great Gatsby is told by Gatsby's very ordinary (and very culpable) neighbor, Nick Carraway.
- Mr. Lockwood, an ordinary guy, narrates Wuthering Heights, about people who live at the peaks and troughs of extreme emotions.
- Frankenstein is a complex series of nested narratives in which the two geniuses, the scientist and the monster, get to speak, but the whole is mediated through the letters of a ship's captain to his sister. He is ambitious, but his decisions render him more human than Victor Frankenstein.
- Atticus Finch might be the superhero of To Kill A Mockingbird, but the story is told by a little girl.
- Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad is a story of traveling through ever-smaller circles to approach the supposed genius of Kurtz, narrated by the more down-to-earth Marlow.
- Captain Horatio Hornblower has Lieutenant Bush.
- Jeeves has Wooster.
- Lord Peter Whimsy has Bunter.
- Winston Smith in 1984 is a very ordinary guy in extraordinary circumstances, under the control of people with unthinkable power, and he responds as just about any of us would.
- Professor Pierre Aronnax narrates 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea, about the crazy genius Captain Nemo.
- In The Chosen by Chaim Potok, Danny Saunders is the genius, and the novel is narrated by his barely-below genius friend Reuven Malter.
- Although Harry Potter is “special,” chosen, and powerful, the narrative focuses so much on his ordinary humanness that he is our stand-in for ourselves, then develops into what we want to become. - (feel free to shoot me for this one) Bella, a human, narrates Twilight: no vampire gets to tell the tale (although a werewolf does narrate a third of the final book).
OK, so that's a lot of examples. And of course there are counter-examples of novels whose third-person narrative focus is on the genius (such as The Agony and the Ecstasy, about Michelangelo) or whose genius is the first-person narrator (such as Chaim Potok's My Name is Asher Lev). And of course there are first-person memoirs by geniuses, such as Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!.
But you get the idea. I think that Sherlock Holmes is probably the best parallel to the Doctor: his is someone who is apparently human, but who has superhuman powers, accompanied by a faithful follower who stands in for the reader/viewer.
You know, this is funny, but isn't the Bible like this in some ways? It's all about God, it's all about Jesus and His one-and-only true story, but it's told by and about all these shabby little humans making awful mistakes all the time. Even in a narrative about a slightly more admirable human like, say, Paul, it's written down and narrated by Luke, the ordinary guy who gives us a glimpse into Paul's great work.
So that's how it works with Rose, Martha, Donna, Amy, and the rest. They are Us. They allow us to watch the Doctor do his amazing stuff from both the inside (as someone close to him) and the outside (as someone not as brilliant as he). And I suspect that's one of the reasons for the mostly ordinary names. They are just little humans—and every little human is as important as the whole universe.
Have you noticed that all of the Doctor's companions and hangers-on are very ordinary people with common names? Rose Tyler, Mickey Smith, Martha Jones, Sarah Jane Smith, Donna Noble.... I think there are a couple of reasons for this.
[Yes, Amelia Pond has a fairy-tale name, and she turns out to be pretty important—but that doesn't invalidate my main ideas here. Hold on.]
First, the point is that he is not picking out someone who is “special” in the world's eyes: not someone famous, or extra-talented, or noteworthy. He's not even really picking people out; he stumbles across someone's path, or she stumbles across his, and they have a connection, and so he invites her along.
The point with that scenario is that any ordinary person has the potential to do really amazing things. An uneducated, lower-class shop girl can save the world, over and over and over, or become a conduit for the Time Vortex, gaining power over life and death, out of the depths of her love and self-sacrifice. A hard-working, intelligent, but otherwise unremarkable medical student can reveal all the truly remarkable depths and complexities of her nature when paired with the Doctor and faced with peril and adventure.
So that's the first point: There are no ordinary humans. Every one can be amazing if given the chance. But that's the point within the narrative, taking the characters as people, inhabiting the world of the fiction.
There is another purpose for the ordinary names altogether when we look at Doctor Who from a literary point of view. This has to do with the narrator. Wait, you say, there is no narrator. There is (thankfully) no voiceover—except in a few odd episodes like “Love and Monsters”, but that's an exception with its own particular purpose. Television is not like written fiction.
When a story is written down, there has to be somebody telling the story. You remember those lessons in high school English class about the narrator: first or third person, limited or omniscient? A movie takes a totally different approach, by filming perspective. It could be filmed from just one character's perspective, but that is rare. I have written a bit about perspective here, in this post about The Hunger Games.
But there is another narrative matter I want to discuss now. I believe that the Doctor Who team used companions with ordinary names because they represent us. Each one is an EveryHuman. She stands in for us, observing the Doctor as we would observe him. This is very important. It is very important to have an outside, ordinary perspective on a Genius or otherwise extraordinary character, so that the reader/viewer will have a way in, a way of understanding the Genius and his relationship to “normal” people. In written fiction, this person often tells the story, so that the reader can identify with the narrator's responses to the Genius. It would be more difficult to identify with the Genius directly, so the writer often puts in an ordinary guy or girl so that we have a way in. Even when the main character is not a genius, but merely someone out of the ordinary in one way or another, we often need a mundane character to bring us in. Even when the narrator does not speak in first person, there is often an ordinary person at the heart of the action.
- We read Sherlock Holmes through the eyes and words of John Watson. (watch this)
- Lord of the Rings is told mostly from a hobbit's perspective, not from a king's or a wizard's.
- The Great Gatsby is told by Gatsby's very ordinary (and very culpable) neighbor, Nick Carraway.
- Mr. Lockwood, an ordinary guy, narrates Wuthering Heights, about people who live at the peaks and troughs of extreme emotions.
- Frankenstein is a complex series of nested narratives in which the two geniuses, the scientist and the monster, get to speak, but the whole is mediated through the letters of a ship's captain to his sister. He is ambitious, but his decisions render him more human than Victor Frankenstein.
- Atticus Finch might be the superhero of To Kill A Mockingbird, but the story is told by a little girl.
- Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad is a story of traveling through ever-smaller circles to approach the supposed genius of Kurtz, narrated by the more down-to-earth Marlow.
- Captain Horatio Hornblower has Lieutenant Bush.
- Jeeves has Wooster.
- Lord Peter Whimsy has Bunter.
- Winston Smith in 1984 is a very ordinary guy in extraordinary circumstances, under the control of people with unthinkable power, and he responds as just about any of us would.
- Professor Pierre Aronnax narrates 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea, about the crazy genius Captain Nemo.
- In The Chosen by Chaim Potok, Danny Saunders is the genius, and the novel is narrated by his barely-below genius friend Reuven Malter.
- Although Harry Potter is “special,” chosen, and powerful, the narrative focuses so much on his ordinary humanness that he is our stand-in for ourselves, then develops into what we want to become. - (feel free to shoot me for this one) Bella, a human, narrates Twilight: no vampire gets to tell the tale (although a werewolf does narrate a third of the final book).
OK, so that's a lot of examples. And of course there are counter-examples of novels whose third-person narrative focus is on the genius (such as The Agony and the Ecstasy, about Michelangelo) or whose genius is the first-person narrator (such as Chaim Potok's My Name is Asher Lev). And of course there are first-person memoirs by geniuses, such as Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman!.
But you get the idea. I think that Sherlock Holmes is probably the best parallel to the Doctor: his is someone who is apparently human, but who has superhuman powers, accompanied by a faithful follower who stands in for the reader/viewer.
You know, this is funny, but isn't the Bible like this in some ways? It's all about God, it's all about Jesus and His one-and-only true story, but it's told by and about all these shabby little humans making awful mistakes all the time. Even in a narrative about a slightly more admirable human like, say, Paul, it's written down and narrated by Luke, the ordinary guy who gives us a glimpse into Paul's great work.
So that's how it works with Rose, Martha, Donna, Amy, and the rest. They are Us. They allow us to watch the Doctor do his amazing stuff from both the inside (as someone close to him) and the outside (as someone not as brilliant as he). And I suspect that's one of the reasons for the mostly ordinary names. They are just little humans—and every little human is as important as the whole universe.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





